It's clear after Sansa turns the tables on Littlefinger that she has had some She trusts and believes Bran because his ultimate trick to get you to believe . Sam suggests a marriage between Rhaegar and Lyanna, and Bran. Petyr Baelish's creepy attraction towards Sansa is derived from his teenage infatuation with Catelyn. Why does Sansa trust Littlefinger so much in the beginning? long term intimate relationships. most likely he views “love” as a weakness. When you have been abused like Sansa Stark, trust is painfully difficult. forced into marriage, beaten, lied to, manipulated, and repeatedly raped. on Baelish's army to save them, he tells her, “We need to trust one another.
He bought wagons, shops, ships, houses. He bought grain when it was plentiful and sold bread when it was scarce. He bought wool from the north and linen from the south and lace from Lys, stored it, moved it, dyed it, sold it. The golden dragons bred and multiplied, and Littlefinger lent them out and brought them home with hatchlings. And in the process, he moved his own men into place. The Keepers of the Keys were his, all four.
plot explanation - Who convinced Sansa that he was guilty? - Movies & TV Stack Exchange
The officers in charge of all three mints. Harbormasters, tax farmers, custom sergeants, wool factors, toll collectors, pursers, wine factors; nine of every ten belonged to Littlefinger. No one had ever thought to question the appointments, and why should they? Littlefinger was no threat to anyone.
He had no banners to call, no army of retainers, no great stronghold, no holdings to speak of, no prospects of a great marriage. This is the terrific backstory of a man who we would consider one of the George R. He has a sharp tongue at times, especially when dealing with Ned Stark in A Game of Thronesbut he knows when to sheathe that tongue, and his real talent lies in his ability to win influence and power, without ever exposing himself to mortal danger.
Every risk he takes is calculated, and though the simple reality of a lowborn lord trying to win the game of thrones comes with inherent danger, he knows how to protect himself within his ambition. The same cannot be said of the corresponding character in the TV shows.
On HBO, Baelish is by turns peevish, impulsive to the point of recklessnessand transparent. Sansa confronted Littlefinger over his heartless sale of her to Ramsay Bolton, just about the most evil character in Westeros this side of Joffrey.
Martin put on the page. Littlefinger never sent Sansa to marry Ramsay in the books. At the end of A Dance With Dragons, Jeyne Poole, beaten, raped repeatedly, undoubtedly scarred for life in every possible way, is on the run with Theon. He rightly knows that even though the Stark family is decimated and scattered across two continents, the name still commands the most respect out of any in the North. As we know, things have progressed very differently on HBO.
In marrying the actual Sansa to Ramsay, he both gave the Bolton Bastard a legitimate claim to Winterfell and squandered whatever influence he had over Sansa. Now, she hates her one-time savior, to the point that she nearly refused his help in retaking Winterfell—which would have denied him even a meager slice of that pie.
His only saving grace, as usual in the show, was luck. LF lies to Bran and says that he doesn't know. LF tries to distract the conversation by talking about Bran's experiences, but Bran promptly brings the topic up again when he says "Chaos is a ladder", another one of LF's quotes while it's not a lie, it's a clear indication of how LF approaches the game of thrones, an indirect admission that he sows chaos to reap the rewards.
Most likely, Bran talked to Sansa soon after, and they started working together. Bran may have taken longer to talk to her his three-eyed-ravenness gets in the way of his humanity from time to time. If Bran was already scheming with Sansa at the time, then it was a mistake to blatantly call LF out on a lie, since they were trying to trap him.
The best assumption we have is that Bran was not aware of a scheme against Littlefinger yet. However, Littlefinger's lies in this conversation may have put fuel to the fire, and caused Bran to proactively seek out Sansa and talk to her. Tangentially, Littlefinger should have understood from this conversation that Bran knows his secret, and likely knows more than what he is saying.
Littlefinger should've hightailed it out of Winterfell at this point, aware of the sword of Damocles that Bran has blatantly pointed out to him.
It feels like bad writing that LF goes on with his business in Winterfell unhindered. Though it's not impossible that it shows a flaw in character, that he takes the risks because he still wants more power. Sansa has seen behind Littlefinger's mask. Sansa has known LF for some time. He has acted like a friend to the family, offered Sansa a way out of King's Landing, implicated Sansa in Joffrey's murder, killed Ser Dontos a well meaning oaf who Sansa had saved from death before in front of her, makes her join in his web of lies, tells her how much he loved her mother and then inappropriately kisses her, kills aunt Lysa to be fair, she did threaten to kill Sansa but she was clearly an unhinged womanand marries her off to Ramsay.
It is true that Sansa was a naive girl for most of these experiences, so she never saw LF's manipulations for what they were at the time. However, Ramsay was the straw that broke the camel's back. Since then, Sansa has changed and matured considerably. She can now look back on the past events, and possibly see them for what they actually were.
LF made some slipups in Winterfell too. He has taught her to lie, he has made her a partner in crime, he has taught her how to think the worst of people. She knows how he works. Most viewers assumed that LF loves Sansa because he sees her as the next best thing to Catelyn.
But given the fact that LF has explained what he knows, it's possible that he sees her as a pseudo-daughter, the daughter him and Catelyn should have had. It's somewhat of a trope that those who consider themselves a parent sub consciously end up teaching their perceived child their "skills of life", to pass on their knowledge.
One of the bigger slipups occurred when he tried to suggest to Sansa that Arya wants to kill her to become Lady of Winterfell. Anyone who knows Arya, knows that she doesn't want to be a lady. If Sansa even just considers Littlefinger being dishonest, withough being certain that he is in fact lying, that can bring back all her past memories of him, and very quickly an image starts to form.
The image of a man who lies and schemes and manipulates, and has no issue whatsoever with throwing people under the bus even if they're friendly to him Ser Dontos, Aunt Lysa, Sansa herself when he married her off to Ramsay.
It's equally likely that Sansa could have approached Bran. However, this makes less sense, if you consider that Bran has been absent from the events for a long time. The only reason Sansa would've approached Bran instead of the other way around is if Sansa is looking for confirmation "checking the video footage". Which is of course also possible, though it seems a bit cheap narratively speaking for characters to start running to Bran for confirmation about their suspicions.
It gets too close to a deus ex machina. Arya joins the plot only after settling some grudges with Sansa. Bran and Sansa both have been eye witness to LF's past shady dealings in different ways. Any conversation between them would very quickly cement the actual truth. This is similar to how Sam and Bran figure out Jon's legitimate birth together. Sam suggests a marriage between Rhaegar and Lyanna, and Bran "checks the video footage".
Bran hasn't seen everything that happens everywhyere, but he has access to it. He only needs to know where to look Sam and Sansa can give him that direction. However, I think that Arya wasn't part of the scheme initially.
The first conflict out on the wooden walkway seems genuine. Arya was bringing up things that she has carried from her childhood, and actively calls Sansa out on undermining Jon, even if only subconsiously.
But then we get to the scene with the faces and the dagger. A quick rundown of the scene. Sansa finds the faces.
Arya explains why she uses them, also revealing a scary and dark side to her character. Sansa is visibly upset and scared by this information. Arya wants to play the game of faces and tries to focus on Sansa undermining Jon.
But Sansa doesn't respond she's too busy talking about the faces and Arya doesn't get a straight answer. Arya picks up the dagger and mentions becoming Lady of Winterfell by cutting Sansa's face off.
Arya then gives Sansa the dagger and walks off.
The big question here is whether Arya was already part of the scheme. If she has been part of the scheme, then the only way that this scene makes sense is that it is staged, intended for Littlefinger who is probably spying to think that there is real animosity between the sisters. But if they are expecting Littlefinger to spy on them, why would Arya give the dagger to Sansa?